Considering NH · Speech / equal punishment
v1.3

Speech and Equal Punishment

This page collects four model bills on New Hampshire's hate-crime sentencing, the state Civil Rights Act, one fair-housing clause, and a general rule on opinion and motive.

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

Version 1.3. None of these bills has been filed or introduced, and none has been reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services (OLS). Not current New Hampshire law.

About this page

This page collects four model bills on New Hampshire's hate-crime sentencing, the state Civil Rights Act, one fair-housing clause, and a general rule on opinion and motive. Each has a short summary, the draft bill text, and talking points. The author is not a licensed attorney, and nothing here is legal advice. None of these bills has been filed or introduced, and none has been reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services (OLS). Blanks (____) mark items OLS would fill in, such as bill and chapter numbers. Effective dates are placeholders.

New Hampshire laws are cited as "RSA" (Revised Statutes Annotated) plus a chapter and section number. In the bill text, words in [brackets] are current law that the bill would delete.

Overview: the four bills together

What this is about

New Hampshire law already punishes assault, threats, vandalism, trespass, harassment, and stalking. In a few places it adds extra punishment or a separate civil case when the conduct was motivated by hostility toward the victim's race, religion, sex, or another listed trait. These four model bills would remove those extra layers and set one rule: the state punishes what a person does, at the same level for every victim, and does not punish opinions.

What the four model bills would do

Bill Statute What it would do
Bill 1 RSA 651:6, I(f) Repeal the longer prison term for crimes motivated by hostility toward a listed trait. Prospective only.
Bill 2 RSA ch. 354-B; RSA 7:8-b, II(c); RSA 21-M:7, II(c) Repeal the state Civil Rights Act. On the effective date, existing orders end, unpaid money awards under it are cancelled, and pending cases are dismissed.
Bill 3 RSA 354-A:14 Repeal the fair-housing coercion/interference section. Pending complaints continue.
Bill 4 New RSA chapter (number TBD) Bar state criminal or civil liability, or a longer sentence, for expressing an opinion, belief, or motive about any characteristic. Keep age/disability/child enhancements. Keep threats, harassment, stalking, fraud, and perjury illegal. Statements can't be the proof in state civil discrimination cases.

Each bill can stand alone. Placeholder effective date for all: January 1, 2028.

What it would not do

No violence, threat, harassment, stalking, property damage, or trespass becomes legal. Discriminatory acts in employment, housing, and public accommodations stay illegal under RSA 354-A, as does retaliation. Enhancements for preying on the elderly, disabled, or children stay. Victims keep their own lawsuits and protective orders. Federal law stays in force (18 U.S.C. §§ 245, 249; 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981, 1983, 1985, 3617, 3631; Title VII; FHA).

Honest limits

The Constitution doesn't require any of this; the Supreme Court upheld motive-based sentencing in 1993. The Attorney General loses a civil tool that works without a conviction. People with Civil Rights Act injunctions lose them, and unpaid awards under that law are cancelled, which could be challenged in court. Some state housing and workplace claims would move to federal agencies and courts. New Hampshire isn't on HUD's current list of certified fair-housing agencies, so no current federal fair-housing funding is at stake, but a future certification could be harder to get. Several drafting points still need Office of Legislative Services review.

Status

Model drafts for discussion. Not filed or introduced. Not reviewed by OLS or a licensed attorney.

What stays illegal

  • Assault, criminal threatening, criminal mischief, criminal trespass, harassment, stalking, and every other crime in the state criminal code, at normal penalties.
  • The other grounds for a longer sentence in RSA 651:6, including crimes that take advantage of a victim's age or disability and crimes against young children. Bill 4 says so in its text.
  • Discriminatory acts in employment, housing, and public accommodations under RSA 354-A, and retaliation (RSA 354-A:19).
  • A victim's own lawsuit for injuries or damage, and protective orders for domestic violence and stalking.
  • Federal hate-crime and civil-rights law: 18 U.S.C. §§ 245 and 249; 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981, 1983, 1985, 3617, and 3631; Title VII; the Fair Housing Act.

Bill 1: Repeal of the hate-crime sentence enhancement (RSA 651:6, I(f))

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

What this is about

RSA 651:6 lists facts a jury can find that open up a longer, "extended" prison term. Paragraph I(f) applies when the defendant "was substantially motivated to commit the crime because of hostility towards the victim's religion, race, creed, sexual orientation, national origin, sex, or gender identity." Two people who commit the same assault can face different maximum sentences depending on why they did it and who the victim was.

What the model bill would do

  1. Repeal RSA 651:6, I(f). The paragraph would show as "Repealed"; the letters after it stay the same, so other laws citing them still work.
  2. Apply only to offenses committed on or after the effective date.
  3. Placeholder effective date: January 1, 2028.

What it would not do

It would not make any crime legal or lower its normal penalty. It would not remove the other extended-term grounds, including force used to take advantage of a victim's age or physical disability (I(d)), theft or fraud against victims 65 or older or with a disability (I(l)), and crimes against children under 13. A judge could still weigh motive inside the normal range. Federal hate-crime law (18 U.S.C. § 249) still applies.

Honest limits

The U.S. Supreme Court held in Wisconsin v. Mitchell (1993) that motive-based enhancements do not violate the First Amendment. This is a policy choice about equal punishment, not a constitutional requirement.

Status

Model draft for discussion. Not filed or introduced. Not reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services.

Draft bill text

                                 HOUSE BILL ____
AN ACT  repealing the extended term of imprisonment for crimes motivated by hostility
        toward certain characteristics of the victim.
SPONSORS: ____                    COMMITTEE: Criminal Justice and Public Safety

Be it Enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court convened:

1 Repeal. RSA 651:6, I(f), relative to extended terms of imprisonment for crimes
substantially motivated by hostility towards the victim's religion, race, creed, sexual
orientation, national origin, sex, or gender identity, is repealed.

2 Applicability. This act shall apply to sentences imposed for offenses committed on or
after the effective date of this act.

3 Effective Date. This act shall take effect January 1, 2028.

Talking points

  1. The underlying crime keeps its full normal penalty. Only the extra enhancement goes.
  2. Every victim of the same assault gets the same maximum sentence.
  3. Longer sentences for preying on the elderly, people with disabilities, and young children stay.
  4. Judges keep ordinary discretion, including motive, inside the normal range.
  5. Prospective only. No sentence is reopened.
  6. Federal hate-crime law stays in force.

Bill 2: Repeal of the state Civil Rights Act (RSA chapter 354-B)

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

What this is about

RSA chapter 354-B lets the Attorney General sue in civil court over force, violence, property damage, trespass, or threats of those acts when motivated by hostility toward race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, sexual orientation, sex, gender identity, or disability. The court can impose up to $5,000 per violation, order restitution, and issue an injunction for up to three years, extendable. Knowingly violating the injunction is a class A misdemeanor. The standard is "clear and convincing evidence," lower than "beyond a reasonable doubt." Cases can be brought against children under 17.

A 2026 law (SB 464, chapter 204) rewrites the core section starting January 1, 2027: motive "in whole or in part," association with a listed group, a reasonable-person threat test, and a line saying protected speech isn't barred.

What the model bill would do

  1. Repeal RSA chapter 354-B, whichever version is in force.
  2. Remove the Civil Rights Act reference from RSA 7:8-b and RSA 21-M:7. The AG's civil rights unit keeps enforcing the Law Against Discrimination.
  3. On the effective date: every order under the chapter ends; every civil penalty, restitution, or other money award under the chapter is vacated and any unpaid balance is cancelled (amounts already paid are not refunded); pending cases are dismissed; and no one can be prosecuted after that date for violating an order, including violations that happened before it.
  4. Placeholder effective date: January 1, 2028.

What it would not do

It would not make force, violence, property damage, trespass, or threats legal; those stay crimes (RSA 631, 633, 634, 635, 644 and others). It would not affect a victim's own lawsuit, or protective orders under RSA 173-B or 633:3-a. It would not change RSA 354-A. Federal civil-rights law stays.

Honest limits

The Attorney General loses a tool that works without a criminal conviction. People protected by a 354-B injunction lose it on the effective date; some could seek a stalking or other protective order, not all would qualify. Unpaid money awards under the chapter, including restitution ordered for victims, would be cancelled. Undoing final court judgments is legally contested and could be challenged in court.

Status

Model draft for discussion. Not filed or introduced. Not reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services.

Draft bill text

                                 HOUSE BILL ____
AN ACT  repealing the civil rights act.
SPONSORS: ____                    COMMITTEE: Judiciary

Be it Enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court convened:

1 Repeal. RSA 354-B, relative to the civil rights act, is repealed.

2 Repeal of Prospective Amendment. 2026, 204:1, relative to civil rights enforcement,
is repealed.

3 Conforming Amendment; Attorney General. Amend RSA 7:8-b, II(c) to read as follows:
  (c) A civil rights unit, which shall be responsible for enforcing the New Hampshire
Law Against Discrimination[, and the New Hampshire Civil Rights Act], bringing civil
enforcement actions on behalf of the public to redress discriminatory acts and civil
rights violations, and enforcing any other state or federal antidiscrimination laws that
authorize the attorney general to enforce them.

4 Conforming Amendment; Department of Justice. Amend RSA 21-M:7, II(c) to read as
follows:
  (c) A civil rights unit, which shall be responsible for enforcing the New Hampshire
Law Against Discrimination[ and the New Hampshire Civil Rights Act].

5 Existing Orders, Judgments, and Pending Actions.
  I. Any temporary restraining order or preliminary or permanent injunction issued under
former RSA 354-B shall terminate on the effective date of this section.
  II. Any judgment or order for a civil penalty, restitution, or other payment of money
entered under former RSA 354-B, whether or not final, is vacated on the effective date
of this section. No such judgment or order shall be enforced, collected, or recorded as
a lien after that date, and any unpaid balance is extinguished. Nothing in this paragraph
shall require the repayment of any amount paid before the effective date of this section.
  III. No action under former RSA 354-B shall be commenced or continued after the
effective date of this section, and any such action then pending shall be dismissed.
  IV. No person shall be prosecuted under former RSA 354-B:4 for conduct occurring on or
after the effective date of this section. No prosecution under former RSA 354-B:4
shall be commenced or continued after the effective date of this section, regardless of
when the conduct occurred.

6 Effective Date.
  I. Section 2 of this act shall take effect upon its passage.
  II. The remainder of this act shall take effect January 1, 2028.

Talking points

  1. Every act this chapter covers is already a crime and stays one.
  2. The chapter adds a second civil case for the same conduct, with a lower standard of proof and penalties up to $5,000 per violation.
  3. The 2027 rewrite widens the motive test to "in whole or in part."
  4. Victims keep their own lawsuits and domestic-violence and stalking orders.
  5. The AG's civil rights unit keeps enforcing the Law Against Discrimination.
  6. On the effective date, existing orders end and unpaid money awards under the chapter are cancelled. Some victims would lose an order or money they were owed.

Bill 3: Repeal of the fair-housing interference section (RSA 354-A:14)

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

What this is about

RSA chapter 354-A bans discrimination in housing, employment, and public accommodations; the Commission for Human Rights handles complaints. RSA 354-A:14 makes it a "civil rights violation to coerce, intimidate, threaten, or interfere with any person" for using or helping others use fair-housing rights. It tracks federal law, 42 U.S.C. § 3617.

What the model bill would do

  1. Repeal RSA 354-A:14.
  2. Leave complaints and cases already started before the effective date unaffected.
  3. Placeholder effective date: January 1, 2028.

What it would not do

It would not change any housing discrimination ban or the retaliation ban (RSA 354-A:19). Threats and violence stay crimes. Federal 42 U.S.C. § 3617 (civil) and § 3631 (criminal) stay in force.

Honest limits

People facing this interference would lose a state forum and would go to HUD, federal court, or the criminal code. HUD can certify a state agency as "substantially equivalent" to federal fair-housing law, which lets it handle federal cases and receive federal funds. New Hampshire does not appear on HUD's public list of certified agencies, so no current federal fair-housing funding depends on this section. If the state seeks certification in the future, this repeal could make it harder or impossible to get. The package author accepts that risk.

Status

Model draft for discussion. Not filed or introduced. Not reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services.

Draft bill text

                                 HOUSE BILL ____
AN ACT  repealing the fair housing provision prohibiting interference, coercion, or
        intimidation.
SPONSORS: ____                    COMMITTEE: Judiciary

Be it Enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court convened:

1 Repeal. RSA 354-A:14, relative to interference, coercion, or intimidation, is repealed.

2 Pending Matters. This act shall not affect any complaint filed with the commission for
human rights or any action commenced before the effective date of this act.

3 Effective Date. This act shall take effect January 1, 2028.

Talking points

  1. Every state housing discrimination ban stays, and so does the retaliation ban.
  2. Threats and violence remain crimes.
  3. Federal law covers the same conduct (42 U.S.C. §§ 3617, 3631).
  4. Complaints already filed continue under the old law.
  5. The trade-off: interference claims move to federal forums, and a future federal "substantially equivalent" certification for NH could be harder to get. NH isn't on HUD's current certified list, so this is a future-certification risk, not a cut to current funding.

Bill 4: Freedom of Opinion and Motive Act (proposed new RSA chapter)

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

What this is about

Freedom of speech is protected by the First Amendment and by Part I, Article 22 of the New Hampshire Constitution. State law can still treat a person's opinion or motive about a group as what makes conduct a violation or a penalty bigger. Bills 1–3 remove current examples. Bill 4 sets a general rule so new ones aren't added.

What the model bill would do

It would create a new, stand-alone chapter of state law that applies to criminal and civil law alike. It would say:

  1. No one can be found guilty, given a longer sentence, or held liable for a civil violation, penalty, or damages under state law for expressing an opinion, belief, or motive about race, ethnicity, religion, national origin, sex, or any other personal characteristic.
  2. No person or group gets protection under state law, criminal or civil, from speech based on a characteristic.
  3. No state offense can include hostility or opinion about the victim's race, religion, sex, or similar trait as an element, and no penalty can be increased on that basis. Longer sentences for taking advantage of a victim's age or disability, and for crimes against children, are expressly kept.
  4. When applying those rules, the state reaches conduct, such as violence against a person or property, and certain unprotected speech, not words or opinions.
  5. In a criminal case, a defendant's own statements can still prove identity, intent, or another element.
  6. In a state civil discrimination case, a person's words or expression can't be used as the proof of discrimination. Discriminatory acts stay illegal and must be proved by the acts.
  7. True threats, criminal threatening, harassment, stalking, solicitation, conspiracy, incitement, fraud, and perjury stay illegal to the extent the Constitution doesn't protect them.
  8. Federal civil remedies are not affected.

Placeholder effective date: January 1, 2028.

What it would not do

It would not legalize threats, harassment, stalking, fraud, perjury, or conspiracy. It would not keep a defendant's words out of an ordinary criminal case. It would not remove sentence enhancements for preying on the elderly, people with disabilities, or children. It would not change federal law, including Title VII and the Fair Housing Act. It doesn't depend on Bills 1–3.

Honest limits

Motive-based sentencing is constitutional under Wisconsin v. Mitchell, so this is a policy choice. Because statements can't be used as proof in state civil discrimination cases, some workplace and housing claims would be harder to win in state forums and would likely move to federal agencies and courts under Title VII and the Fair Housing Act. That shift could make it harder for New Hampshire to get future federal certification that depends on state law matching federal law. The bill protects opinions about personal characteristics from lawsuits, but it does not end defamation suits over false statements of fact.

Status

Model draft for discussion. Not filed or introduced. Not reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services.

Draft bill text

                                 HOUSE BILL ____
AN ACT  relative to freedom of opinion and expression of motive.
SPONSORS: ____                    COMMITTEE: Judiciary

Be it Enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court convened:

1 Statement of Purpose. The general court finds that freedom of speech is secured by the
First Amendment to the United States Constitution and by Part I, Article 22 of the New
Hampshire constitution, and that the state shall not impose criminal liability or
additional punishment, or civil liability or penalty, for the content of a person's
opinions or beliefs about any group or characteristic.

2 New Chapter; Freedom of Opinion and Expression of Motive. Amend the RSA by inserting
after chapter ___ the following new chapter:
                              CHAPTER ___
               FREEDOM OF OPINION AND EXPRESSION OF MOTIVE
  ___:1 Definition. In this chapter, "laws of this state" means the
statutes, common law, administrative rules, ordinances, and orders of this state and its
political subdivisions, whether criminal or civil.
  ___:2 Freedom of Opinion and Expression of Motive.
  I. No person shall be guilty of an offense, be subject to an enhanced or extended
penalty, or be liable for a civil violation, civil penalty, or damages under the criminal
or civil laws of this state, for expressing an opinion, belief, or motive concerning
race, ethnicity, religion, national origin, sex, or any other personal characteristic of
any person or group.
  II. No person, group, or class shall be afforded protection under the criminal or civil
laws of this state from speech on the basis of race, ethnicity, religion, national
origin, sex, or any other characteristic.
  III. No offense defined by the laws of this state shall include as an element, and no
penalty shall be increased on the basis of, the defendant's hostility, bias, prejudice,
opinion, or belief relating to the race, ethnicity, religion, creed, national origin,
sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, or other personal characteristic of the
victim. This paragraph shall not apply to any element or extended or enhanced penalty
based on the victim's age or physical or mental disability, or on the defendant's intent
to take advantage of the victim's age or physical or mental disability or condition,
including RSA 651:6, I(d), (e), (k), (l), (m), (n), (o), and (p).
  IV. In applying paragraphs I through III, the state shall impose liability only for
conduct, such as physical violence or physical aggression against a person or property,
or for speech described in subparagraph V(b), and not for words spoken or opinions or
motives expressed.
  V. Nothing in this section shall be construed to:
    (a) Bar the admission, in a criminal prosecution, of a defendant's statements as
evidence of identity, intent, knowledge, or another element of an offense that does not
depend on the content of the defendant's opinion, subject to the rules of evidence;
provided, however, that no person's words, speech, or expression shall be admissible or
used as proof of discrimination, discriminatory intent, or discriminatory motive in any
civil action or administrative proceeding under RSA 354-A or any other civil
anti-discrimination law of this state;
    (b) Protect a true threat, including criminal threatening under RSA 631:4;
harassment under RSA 644:4; stalking under RSA 633:3-a; solicitation of or conspiracy to
commit an offense; incitement to imminent lawless action; fraud; perjury; or other
speech integral to criminal conduct, to the extent such speech is unprotected under the
United States Constitution or the New Hampshire constitution; or
    (c) Limit any civil remedy available under federal law.

3 Effective Date. This act shall take effect January 1, 2028.

Talking points

  1. State law punishes conduct, not opinion, and the rule now applies to civil law too.
  2. Threats, harassment, stalking, fraud, perjury, solicitation, and conspiracy stay illegal; the bill names them.
  3. Prosecutors can still use a defendant's words to prove who did it and what they intended.
  4. Discrimination cases at the state level must rest on what someone did, not what they said.
  5. Sentence enhancements for preying on the elderly, disabled, or children are kept in the text.
  6. A future legislature could still restore motive-based penalties, but it would have to amend or repeal this chapter to do so.
  7. Federal law is untouched.

MODEL DRAFT. Not legal advice. Not prepared by a licensed attorney. Not filed or introduced.

Download this package as a text file (v1.3)

For lawmakers · Back to the map